Section 431 election explained: what UK founders must do when issuing shares to employees

- 14 days, no exceptions: the employer and employee must sign a section 431 election within 14 days of the employee acquiring shares. A late election has no effect.
- Tax now, not later: the election taxes the unrestricted value at acquisition so later growth is a capital gain at 18% or 24%. Without it, part of the exit value is taxed as income, with PAYE and NIC if the shares are readily convertible.
- Keep it, do not file it: the election stays with your records and the share issue goes on the annual ERS return by 6 July. EMI options exercised at market value get a deemed election.
A section 431 election is a joint election by an employer and employee, signed within 14 days of the employee acquiring shares, under section 431 of ITEPA 2003. It treats restricted shares as unrestricted for tax, so income tax is paid up front on their full value and future growth is taxed as a capital gain.
This guide explains why the election matters, what happens without one (with worked figures), the 14-day deadline, how to complete and report it, and how it applies to EMI options.
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Who makes it? | The employer and the employee, jointly |
| Deadline | Within 14 days of the employee acquiring the shares; no extensions |
| Form | Wording in a form approved by HMRC, usually a schedule to the subscription or exercise documents |
| Filing | Not sent to HMRC; both parties keep a signed copy and the share issue is reported on the annual ERS return |
| Effect | Income tax is paid at acquisition on the unrestricted value, and later growth is taxed as a capital gain |
| Risk | If the shares fall in value, the tax paid up front is not refunded |
| EMI options | An election is deemed to be made when EMI options granted at market value are exercised |
What is a section 431 election?
A section 431 election is a choice to be taxed on shares as if they carried no restrictions. It matters because almost every share a startup issues to an employee or director is a restricted security.
Shares acquired because of employment are "employment-related securities". Private company shares usually come with restrictions, such as compulsory transfer if the holder leaves, bad leaver pricing or limits on selling. Those restrictions reduce what the shares are worth, so HMRC uses two values:
- Actual market value (AMV): the value with the restrictions.
- Unrestricted market value (UMV): the value if the restrictions did not exist.
Without an election, the gap between the two is not taxed when the shares are acquired. Instead, a proportion of the shares' future value is taxed as employment income when the restrictions are lifted or the shares are sold. The election closes that gap at the start. A full election under section 431(1) ignores all restrictions; a partial election under section 431(2) ignores only some. Most startups use the full election.
What happens if you do not make the election?
Without an election, part of the growth in the shares' value is taxed as income, at up to 45% plus any National Insurance, rather than as a capital gain at 18% or 24%.
The taxable proportion is fixed at acquisition. It equals the share of the unrestricted value that was neither paid for nor taxed at the time. That fraction is then applied to the unrestricted value at the later chargeable event, such as a sale.
Worked example
An employee buys 10,000 shares for £1 each, which is their restricted value (AMV). Their unrestricted value (UMV) is £1.50. Because the employee paid full AMV, there is no tax at acquisition, but one-third of the UMV (£0.50 of £1.50) has not been taxed. Three years later the company is sold for £10 a share.
| 10,000 shares, sold at £10 | With s431 election | Without election |
|---|---|---|
| Taxed as income at acquisition | £5,000 (£0.50 a share) | £0 |
| Taxed as income on sale | £0 | £33,333 (one-third of £100,000) |
| Capital gain on sale | £85,000 | £56,667 |
| Income tax at 40% | £2,000 | £13,333 |
| CGT at 24% | £20,400 | £13,600 |
| Total tax | £22,400 | £26,933, plus NIC if the shares are readily convertible |
| The employee pays £1 a share (the restricted value); the unrestricted value is £1.50. Ignores the CGT annual exempt amount. Amounts taxed as income are added to the CGT base cost. | ||
The election costs £2,000 up front and saves about £4,500 in total here. The saving grows with the exit value, and it is larger still if NIC applies.
The same logic applies when shares are bought at a discount. If UMV is £1, AMV is £0.80 and the employee pays £0.50, then £0.30 a share is taxed at acquisition. Without an election, 20% of the value at sale (£2.00 a share at £10) is later taxed as income. With an election, £0.50 a share is taxed at acquisition and nothing more is taxed as income.
Is the charge collected through PAYE or Self Assessment?
How the later income charge is collected depends on whether the shares are readily convertible assets (RCAs). Shares are RCAs if there are arrangements to sell them, which is usually the case on an exit. If they are RCAs, the employer must operate PAYE and pay employer NIC at 15%, and employee NIC also applies. If they are not, the employee reports the income through Self Assessment and no NIC is due.
Why buyers ask for elections
On an exit, the buyer's lawyers will ask for copies of section 431 elections for every employee shareholder. A missing election can mean a PAYE and NIC liability that stays with the company after completion. Expect the buyer to ask for an indemnity, a retention from the price or, in a smaller deal, a price reduction.
Income tax vs capital gains tax rates
The election matters because income tax and NIC rates are much higher than capital gains tax rates.
- Income: 20%, 40% or 45% income tax, plus employee NIC (8% or 2%) and employer NIC (15%) if the shares are readily convertible.
- Capital gains: 18% within the basic rate band and 24% above it.
- Business Asset Disposal Relief: 18% from 6 April 2026 on qualifying gains, up to the lifetime limit. Employees usually need at least 5% of the shares to qualify, unless the shares came from EMI options.
When must a section 431 election be made?
Within 14 days of the date the employee acquires the shares. HMRC has no power to accept a late election.
The 14 days run from the day after acquisition: if shares are acquired on 1 March, the election must be signed by the end of 15 March. HMRC's Employment Related Securities Manual confirms that an election made outside the window has no effect. Prepare the election with the subscription or exercise documents and have both parties sign at completion. Electronic signatures are valid.
How to make a section 431 election step by step
Making the election takes six steps, and none of them involve sending anything to HMRC at the time.
- Assume the shares are restricted. Leaver provisions, transfer restrictions and drag-along rights in your articles or shareholders' agreement usually make them so.
- Value the shares. Work out AMV and UMV, with a professional valuation if the amounts are material. The difference between the price paid and UMV is taxed at acquisition.
- Use the approved wording. HMRC has approved standard forms of election. Use or reproduce the wording exactly, including the names, the date of acquisition, the number and class of shares and whether it is a full or partial election.
- Sign within 14 days. The employer and the employee each sign. In a group, the employer is the employing company, which may not be the company issuing the shares.
- Keep copies. Store the signed election with the share issue records in your cap table and give the employee a copy. HMRC can ask to see it.
- Report on the ERS return. Register the arrangement on HMRC's Employment Related Securities (ERS) online service and report the share acquisition on the annual return by 6 July after the end of the tax year. A late return triggers an automatic £100 penalty, with further penalties if it is still outstanding three and six months later.
In Undo Capital's ledger-based cap table, the signed election can be attached to the share issue transaction it relates to, and documents go out for e-signature with a legal audit trail, so the date of signature is recorded.
Do you need a section 431 election for EMI options?
Usually not. Under section 431A of ITEPA 2003, when EMI options granted at market value are exercised, the employee and employer are treated as having made a section 431 election.
The deemed election does not apply if the option was granted at a discount to market value, or to shares acquired from options that are not EMI options, such as unapproved options. In those cases, sign an election within 14 days of exercise. Many advisers include a precautionary election in every exercise pack anyway, because it costs nothing and removes doubt. Our guide to EMI option schemes covers the wider rules, and EMI vs unapproved options compares the tax.
Common section 431 election mistakes
Most problems come from timing and record-keeping rather than from the election itself.
- Leaving it until after completion. If signatures are chased after a funding round closes, the 14 days can pass. Sign at completion.
- The wrong employer signs. In a group, the employing company must be party to the election.
- Forgetting founders. Founders who are directors are employees for these rules. Shares issued to them after incorporation, or in a share exchange into a new holding company, may need fresh elections.
- Assuming an old election covers new shares. Each acquisition needs its own election, including shares received on a share exchange or reorganisation.
- Losing the paperwork. If you cannot produce the election in due diligence, the buyer will treat it as missing. Keep elections with the share records you update at each round.
- Undervaluing UMV. If HMRC later argues UMV was higher, more tax is due at acquisition. Keep the valuation evidence.
Keep every election with the share issue it belongs to
Elections are easy to sign and easy to lose, and buyers check for them. Undo Capital's cap table software records each share issue and option exercise as a ledger transaction with its documents attached, routes the election and share certificate to the right signatories for e-signature, and keeps signed copies in your data room ready for due diligence. Undo Capital does not give tax advice, so agree valuations with your accountant.
FAQs
What is a section 431 election?
It is a joint election between an employee and their employer under section 431 of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003. It treats restricted shares as unrestricted for tax purposes, so income tax is paid at acquisition on the full unrestricted value and any later growth is taxed as a capital gain rather than as employment income.
What is the deadline for a section 431 election?
The election must be signed by both parties within 14 days of the employee acquiring the shares. The days run from the day after acquisition, so shares acquired on 1 March need an election signed by the end of 15 March. HMRC cannot extend the deadline, and a late election has no effect.
Do I need a section 431 election for EMI options?
Usually not. Section 431A of ITEPA 2003 deems an election to have been made when EMI options granted at market value are exercised. You still need a signed election within 14 days if the options were granted at a discount or are unapproved options. Many advisers include an election in every exercise pack anyway as a precaution, because it costs nothing.
What happens if you do not make a section 431 election?
A proportion of the shares' later value, fixed by the gap between what was paid and the unrestricted value at acquisition, is taxed as employment income when the restrictions lift or the shares are sold. If the shares are readily convertible assets, PAYE and NIC apply; otherwise the employee reports the income through Self Assessment.
Do you send a section 431 election to HMRC?
No. The employer and employee each keep a signed copy, and HMRC can ask to see it. The company reports the share acquisition on its annual Employment Related Securities return, filed online by 6 July after the end of the tax year. A late return triggers an automatic £100 penalty, with more if it stays outstanding.
References
- Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003, section 431: election for full or partial disapplication
- Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003, section 431A: EMI deemed election
- ERSM30460: Restricted securities: elections to exclude outstanding restrictions - HMRC internal manual
- ETASSUM57150: EMI: Section 431 election - HMRC internal manual
- Capital Gains Tax rates - GOV.UK
Disclosure Notice: This communication is issued by Undo Capital Limited (“Undo Capital”) and is provided strictly for informational purposes only. It contains general information and should not be relied upon as accounting, business, financial, investment, legal, tax, or other professional advice. Undo Capital is not regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and does not provide investment, financial, or tax advice. Our services are designed to assist startups and businesses with company formation, legal agreements, and funding-related documentation. Nothing in this communication constitutes, or should be construed as, a recommendation, offer, or solicitation to purchase or sell any security or financial instrument.
Participation in startups and early-stage enterprises involves significant risk. Such investments may be illiquid, may not generate dividends, may be subject to dilution, and may result in the total loss of invested capital. Any decisions or actions that may affect your business or personal interests should be taken only after seeking advice from suitably qualified professional advisors, and should form part of a balanced and diversified portfolio. This communication may contain links to third-party websites. The inclusion of such links does not imply endorsement, approval, investigation, or verification by Undo Capital. We accept no responsibility or liability for the content, accuracy, or use of information contained on any third-party websites.
Latest articles

SEIS and EIS tax relief calculator

