SAFE vs convertible note: which is right for your startup raise?

Contents
Explore with AI
SAFE vs convertible note: which is right for your startup raise?
Key takeaways
  • Debt or not: a SAFE has no interest and no maturity date and converts at the next priced round; a convertible note is a loan that accrues interest and must convert or be repaid by its maturity date.
  • Post-money SAFEs shift dilution to founders: each extra SAFE comes out of the founders’ share, not earlier SAFE holders’. Two £400k SAFEs at a £4m cap take founders from 100% to 80% before any priced round.
  • UK SEIS/EIS rounds need an ASA: neither SAFEs nor convertible loan notes qualify for relief. An advance subscription agreement can, if it meets HMRC’s conditions, including a long-stop date within six months.
SEIS/EIS Advance Assurance
Check your SEIS/EIS eligibility in 60 seconds

Answer a few questions for a free eligibility check, then build your HMRC Advance Assurance application in Undo, reviewed by UK tax experts before submission.

Cap table
Keep your cap table accurate and Companies House ready

Import your company from Companies House, record every share issue with its legal date and see your cap table at any point in its history.

Funding rounds
Run your next funding round in one place

Model valuation and dilution, generate SEIS/EIS-ready documents, collect e-signatures and update your cap table automatically when the round closes.

Data room
Share an investor-ready data room

Upload your documents, share them with investors and see exactly who viewed what, with page-level engagement analytics.

Option pool
Plan and manage your option pool

Model your option pool, track grants and see fully diluted ownership alongside your cap table.

Undo Capital
Raise and manage equity in one place

SEIS/EIS Advance Assurance, cap table, funding rounds and data room for UK founders. Free to start.

A SAFE (simple agreement for future equity) is not debt: it has no interest and no maturity date, and converts into shares at your next priced round. A convertible note is a loan that accrues interest and must convert or be repaid by a maturity date. Choose a SAFE for speed, a note when investors want protection.

In practice the investor in front of you often decides the instrument, and the dilution maths decides how much it costs you. This guide compares the two term by term, works through a post-money example, and sets out when each one fits.

UK founders have one question to answer first: are your investors claiming SEIS or EIS relief? Neither a SAFE nor a convertible loan note qualifies, which is why UK rounds often use an advance subscription agreement (ASA) instead. We cover that below.

Quick decision tree

Five questions settle most cases. Answer them before anyone drafts a document.

  • Are your investors claiming SEIS or EIS relief? Do not use a SAFE or a convertible loan note. Use an advance subscription agreement (ASA) or issue shares directly.
  • Need to close several small cheques quickly, with no interest or maturity date? Start with a SAFE.
  • Does the investor want a repayment claim and accrued interest? Consider a convertible note.
  • Is a priced round close? Either can work. Model both outcomes on your cap table.
  • Already carrying several SAFEs, notes or promised options? Clean up the cap table before adding another instrument.

What is a SAFE (simple agreement for future equity)?

A SAFE is a contract. The investor gives you money now. In return, you promise them equity later, usually when you close your next priced funding round. That is the whole idea behind a simple agreement for future equity.

Y Combinator created the SAFE in 2013 to make early-stage fundraising faster. Before the YC SAFE, founders leaned on convertible notes, which carried legal baggage. The SAFE stripped that away. YC’s current forms are drafted for US companies, which matters if you are raising in the UK (see below).

Here is what a SAFE is not. It is not a loan. It carries no interest rate. It has no maturity date, so there is no date on which the investor can demand repayment. (If the company is sold or wound up before the SAFE converts, the SAFE pays out under its own terms.) That is why the SAFE became the default for so many US pre-seed deals: a fast way to raise without setting a valuation yet.

A standard safe agreement runs only a few pages. Less legal time means lower cost. For a founder racing to close a round, that matters.

How a SAFE converts into equity

A SAFE converts into shares at a trigger event, usually your next priced round, at a price set by its cap or discount.

Until then the investor holds a contractual right, not shares. When the trigger event happens, their money turns into shares and they become a shareholder.

The conversion price depends on two terms: the valuation cap and the discount. Together they decide how many shares the investor receives for taking the early risk.

Valuation cap and discount explained

A valuation cap is the highest company valuation at which a SAFE converts. Say an investor puts money in on a SAFE with a £5m cap. Your priced round later values the company at £10m. The investor still converts as if the company were worth £5m, so they get roughly twice the shares for their money. The cap rewards them for taking the early risk.

A discount works alongside the cap. A 20% discount means the SAFE holder converts at 80% of the new round's price. Most SAFEs use a cap, a discount, or both, whichever is better for the investor.

What is a convertible note?

A convertible note is debt that turns into equity. The investor lends you money. Later, that loan converts into shares instead of being repaid in cash. People also call this convertible debt. In the UK the usual form is the convertible loan note (CLN).

Three terms define a convertible note. First, an interest rate, often in the single digits, which accrues over time. Second, a maturity date, the deadline by which the note must convert or be repaid. Third, the same valuation cap and discount mechanics that a SAFE uses.

Think of it as a loan first and equity second. Until conversion, it is a debt on your books. If your priced round does not happen before the maturity date, the note can come due. That is the core tension founders feel with convertible notes.

What are convertible notes good for? They give investors a fallback: if the company stalls, the debt and accrued interest still exist. Both SAFEs and notes belong to the wider family of convertible securities, instruments that start as one thing and become equity later.

UK convertible loan notes follow the same pattern: interest usually accrues, there is a maturity date, and the note sits on the balance sheet as debt until it converts. One point matters for UK rounds: shares issued on conversion of a loan do not qualify for SEIS or EIS, because the investor is not paying cash for new shares when they are issued. Our guide to convertible loan notes covers the UK mechanics.

How a convertible note converts

A note converts when you close a qualifying priced round, and principal plus interest both turn into shares.

The cap and discount set the conversion price, just as with a SAFE.

The difference is the clock. A SAFE has no deadline. A convertible note has a maturity date, commonly one to two years after signing. Miss it, and you and your investor must renegotiate, extend, or repay. That deadline is the price of the debt protection.

SAFE vs convertible note: the key differences

The biggest split is simple: a convertible note is debt and a SAFE is not. Interest, maturity, repayment risk and investor protection all follow from that.

FeatureSAFEConvertible note
Legal natureNot debtDebt (a loan)
InterestNoneYes, accrues over time
Maturity dateNoneYes, a hard deadline
ComplexityLow: a few pagesHigher: more terms
Speed to closeFasterSlower
Investor protectionLowerHigher
Repayment risk for the founderNo repayment datePossible at maturity
SEIS/EIS relief (UK)Does not qualifyDoes not qualify (conversion shares are not paid for in cash)

A SAFE is built for speed and simplicity. A convertible note is built for protection. Neither is "better." They serve different rooms.

For early founders, the appeal of the SAFE is real. Fewer terms mean fewer arguments and lower legal bills. A standardised SAFE also means investors already know the document, so negotiation moves fast.

The appeal of the note is the safety net. The interest and the maturity date give the investor bargaining power and a defined exit if things go sideways. Some investors will not write a cheque without it.

Pre-money vs post-money SAFEs

A post-money SAFE fixes the investor's percentage at signing, so every later SAFE dilutes the founders rather than earlier SAFE holders. That is the main reason to model before you sign. To see the effect on ownership, try our funding round calculator.

When YC first launched the SAFE, it was pre-money. In 2018, YC switched to a post-money SAFE, and that change matters more than most founders realise.

Here is the pre money vs post money difference in plain terms. A pre-money SAFE calculates the investor's ownership before the new investment is added to the company's value. A post-money SAFE calculates it after. That sounds small. It is not.

With the post-money model, the investor's ownership percentage is fixed and clear at signing. They know exactly what slice they own once the SAFE converts. Certainty for them.

But that certainty shifts dilution onto you. In a pre vs post money valuation comparison, the post-money structure means each additional SAFE dilutes the founders and existing shareholders, not the earlier SAFE holders. The priced round then dilutes everyone, SAFE holders included. Stack several post-money SAFEs, and the founder dilution adds up quietly. Many founders only see the full picture when they build their cap table for the priced round.

Worked example: two post-money SAFEs, then a priced round

You raise £400,000 on a post-money SAFE with a £4m cap, so that investor is buying 10% (£400k ÷ £4m). A month later you raise a second £400,000 SAFE at the same cap. Then you close a £2m priced round at an £8m pre-money valuation (£10m post-money), so the new investor takes 20%. Option pool ignored for simplicity.

HolderAfter SAFE 1After SAFE 2After £2m priced round
Founders90%80%64%
SAFE 1 (£400k, £4m cap)10%10%8%
SAFE 2 (£400k, £4m cap)n/a10%8%
New investor (£2m)n/an/a20%
SAFE percentages shown on an as-converted basis. SAFE 2 comes entirely out of the founders’ share; the priced round then dilutes everyone by 20%.

With one SAFE the founders would end at 72%. The second £400,000 costs them another 8 points, and SAFE 1 does not move at all until the priced round. With a pre-money SAFE, that second cheque would have diluted SAFE 1 too.

Run the numbers before you sign; a few minutes of modelling can save several points of ownership.

UK founders: SAFEs, ASAs and SEIS/EIS tax relief

If your investors want SEIS or EIS relief, neither a SAFE nor a convertible loan note will work; a compliant ASA or a direct share issue will.

Most UK angels invest through SEIS or EIS. SEIS gives investors 50% income tax relief on up to £200,000 a year, in companies raising up to £250,000 under the scheme. EIS gives 30% income tax relief on up to £1m a year (£2m where the excess goes into knowledge-intensive companies). Demand is real: HMRC’s latest figures show a record £276 million raised by 2,430 companies under SEIS in 2024-25.

The investor must subscribe for new, full-risk ordinary shares and pay for them in cash when they are issued. A SAFE gives only a right to future shares, and shares issued on conversion of a loan are paid for by cancelling the debt, not with new money.

The UK instrument that can qualify is the advance subscription agreement (ASA). The investor pays now and receives shares later, which is close to how a SAFE works in practice. To keep SEIS or EIS relief, the ASA must meet HMRC’s conditions:

  • the money is paid in full up front;
  • no interest is paid and the investor has no right to a refund;
  • the agreement cannot be varied or transferred;
  • it converts only into ordinary shares, on conversion terms fixed when it is signed;
  • it has a long-stop date no more than six months after the agreement.

Our guide to advance subscription agreements explains how to set one up. If you raise SEIS and EIS in the same round, the SEIS shares must be issued before the EIS shares, on an earlier day, so plan the conversion dates around that.

Before you choose any instrument, confirm where the company and investors are based, whether SEIS or EIS relief is part of the offer, when the shares must be issued, and how the instrument will show in your fully diluted cap table. This is not tax or legal advice: complex or cross-border rounds need a qualified adviser.

When should you use a SAFE?

A SAFE fits the earliest stage, when speed matters and investors are comfortable without debt protection.

Use a SAFE when speed matters most. At pre-seed, when you are raising from angels and early funds, a SAFE lets you close in days, not weeks.

Use a SAFE when you do not want to set a valuation yet. It lets you raise now and price the company later, when you have more traction to negotiate with.

Use a SAFE for US-style raises. American angels and accelerators expect it. The document is familiar, the terms are standard, and the legal cost is low. If your investors are comfortable with a YC SAFE, it is usually the path of least friction. If your investors are UK angels claiming SEIS or EIS, it is the wrong tool: use an ASA.

In short: the earliest stage, friendly investors, a need for speed. That is SAFE territory.

When should you use a convertible note?

A convertible note fits when the investor wants a repayment claim, interest or a deadline.

Use a convertible note when investors want debt protection. Some investors, especially outside the US, will not invest without the security a loan provides.

Use a note when a deadline helps. The maturity date creates pressure to reach a priced round. For some founders, that pressure is useful. For others, it is a risk.

Use a note when interest matters to the investor. Accrued interest rewards them for the wait and the risk. If your investor thinks like a lender, a convertible note speaks their language.

In short, when the other side of the table wants security, a fixed timeline, or both, a convertible note fits better than a SAFE.

A stage-based decision framework

The right instrument also depends on your stage, how much you are raising and the milestone the money has to reach. The bands below are rough guides, not rules.

Pre-seed: under £500,000

A SAFE can suit several small cheques when pricing the company would be premature. Use one form, set a ceiling on the total and model every close. If investors want SEIS, which covers up to £250,000 for the company, use an ASA or a direct share issue instead. Renaming a US SAFE does not change the tax result.

Seed: £500,000 to £2 million

At this size convenience can hide dilution: SAFEs with different caps convert at different prices. If the lead investor wants governance rights now, a priced round may be cleaner. A convertible note can bridge to a known milestone if the maturity date is realistic and you model the interest as it accrues.

Series A preparation

List every SAFE, convertible note, ASA, option, warrant and promised grant. Test conversion at the cap, the discount and the expected round price, then add the larger option pool the new investor is likely to ask for. A clean model answers the question the documents cannot: who owns what after conversion?

Mixing instruments

You can use both SAFEs and notes, but standardising is safer. Each extra instrument adds its own triggers, rights and prices, so mix them only for a clear commercial reason.

Which should you choose: a SAFE or a convertible note?

Match the instrument to the investor: SAFE for US-style angels and accelerators, ASA for UK angels claiming SEIS or EIS, convertible note when the investor wants protection. The room often decides before you do.

If your investors are US angels or accelerator-backed funds, default to a SAFE. It is faster, cheaper, and founder-friendly, with no interest and no maturity date hanging over you.

If they are UK angels investing under SEIS or EIS, default to an ASA.

If your investors want protection, a deadline, or accruing interest, a convertible note is the honest answer. Do not fight it. Match the instrument to the relationship.

Then run the dilution maths. Whichever you pick, model the cap, the discount, and the pre-money vs post-money effect before you sign. A bad cap can cost you more equity than any legal fee ever will.

Finally, ask what happens if the next round is late, smaller than planned or never happens. That is where the two instruments differ most.

Common mistakes founders make

Most problems come from dilution nobody modelled or tax relief promised on the wrong instrument.

  • Treating the valuation cap as the company’s valuation. It is a conversion mechanism, not the price of a priced round.
  • Ignoring total SAFE dilution. Several small post-money SAFEs can sell more of the company than you intended.
  • Forgetting note interest. Accrued interest usually converts too, so a note grows even when your bank balance does not.
  • Using inconsistent definitions. Terms such as “qualified financing” and “company capitalisation” vary between documents and change the conversion result.
  • Promising SEIS or EIS relief on the wrong instrument. SAFEs and convertible loan notes do not qualify. Use a compliant ASA or a direct share issue, and get Advance Assurance before you promise relief.
  • Updating the cap table only at conversion. Record contingent ownership when each agreement is signed.

Managing the round after signing

Choosing the instrument is only the first step. You still need signed documents, board approvals, investor records and an accurate ownership ledger, and every close should show up in your fully diluted cap table on the day it happens.

Undo Capital's funding rounds module supports equity rounds, advance subscription agreements and convertible loans, and each close is recorded as an event in a ledger-based cap table. Its scenario modelling lets you run the example above with your own caps and round sizes before you sign, and the SEIS/EIS Advance Assurance module drafts the HMRC application from your pitch deck and financial model for review and submission.

If your round is heading towards an ASA, start with SEIS/EIS Advance Assurance in Undo Capital, then model each close on your cap table before the priced round.

FAQs

1

What is the difference between a SAFE and a convertible note?

A SAFE is not a loan. It has no interest and no maturity date, and it converts to equity at a future priced round. A convertible note is debt that accrues interest and must convert, or be repaid, by a maturity date. In the UK, neither qualifies for SEIS or EIS relief.

2

Is a SAFE debt or equity?

Neither, at the time of signing. SAFE stands for simple agreement for future equity: a contractual right to receive shares later. It carries no interest and no repayment date, and the investor only becomes a shareholder when it converts at a priced round, or is paid out under its own terms if the company is sold first.

3

Do SAFEs or convertible loan notes qualify for SEIS or EIS?

No. SEIS and EIS require new, full-risk ordinary shares paid for in cash when issued. UK founders usually use an advance subscription agreement (ASA) instead, which can qualify if it meets HMRC’s conditions, including a long-stop date no more than six months away.

4

What happens to my SAFE when we raise a Series A?

The SAFE converts under its cap, discount or other pricing rule, and the new Series A money then dilutes all existing holders, including the converted SAFE holders. Check the definition of company capitalisation and any new option pool before you sign the priced-round term sheet, because both change how many shares each SAFE receives.

5

What is the difference between a pre-money and post-money SAFE?

A pre-money SAFE calculates the investor’s ownership before the SAFE money is added. A post-money SAFE, now the YC standard, calculates it after, so the investor’s percentage is fixed at the cap and any later SAFEs dilute the founders rather than earlier SAFE holders.

Disclosure Notice: This communication is issued by Undo Capital Limited (“Undo Capital”) and is provided strictly for informational purposes only. It contains general information and should not be relied upon as accounting, business, financial, investment, legal, tax, or other professional advice. Undo Capital is not regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and does not provide investment, financial, or tax advice. Our services are designed to assist startups and businesses with company formation, legal agreements, and funding-related documentation. Nothing in this communication constitutes, or should be construed as, a recommendation, offer, or solicitation to purchase or sell any security or financial instrument.
‍
Participation in startups and early-stage enterprises involves significant risk. Such investments may be illiquid, may not generate dividends, may be subject to dilution, and may result in the total loss of invested capital. Any decisions or actions that may affect your business or personal interests should be taken only after seeking advice from suitably qualified professional advisors, and should form part of a balanced and diversified portfolio. This communication may contain links to third-party websites. The inclusion of such links does not imply endorsement, approval, investigation, or verification by Undo Capital. We accept no responsibility or liability for the content, accuracy, or use of information contained on any third-party websites.

SEIS/EIS Advance Assurance
Check your SEIS/EIS eligibility in 60 seconds

Answer a few questions for a free eligibility check, then build your HMRC Advance Assurance application in Undo, reviewed by UK tax experts before submission.

Cap table
Keep your cap table accurate and Companies House ready

Import your company from Companies House, record every share issue with its legal date and see your cap table at any point in its history.

Funding rounds
Run your next funding round in one place

Model valuation and dilution, generate SEIS/EIS-ready documents, collect e-signatures and update your cap table automatically when the round closes.

Data room
Share an investor-ready data room

Upload your documents, share them with investors and see exactly who viewed what, with page-level engagement analytics.

Option pool
Plan and manage your option pool

Model your option pool, track grants and see fully diluted ownership alongside your cap table.

Undo Capital
Raise and manage equity in one place

SEIS/EIS Advance Assurance, cap table, funding rounds and data room for UK founders. Free to start.

Resources

Latest articles